Wyrmworks PublishingRole-Playing GamesDungeons & DragonsFree5eThe Next Edition of Dungeons and Dragons Has No Dungeon Master

Comments

The Next Edition of Dungeons and Dragons Has No Dungeon Master — 6 Comments

  1. This all sounds very reasonable to me. I personally take a long time to change my language sometimes. I can however, change when it is the right thing to do.
    Bruce the DM

    • And in a lot of ways, that was what it came down to — if we as a culture can change our vocabulary to avoid using hurtful slurs and insensitive terminology, we hope that the gaming culture can do the same. Even if our terminology choices don’t get adopted (like the way we’re using some A5E terms but not others), we hope that this will get people thinking and talking. And if someone comes up with something better, fantastic.

  2. I’m on board with the changes, but “Adept” says “MAGIC” to me. The “Apprentice Adept” series, the “Magician: Adept” and “Magician: Master” books, they’re about mastering magic. Which is very different from the function of a tabletop Monk, who’s about mastering the body and possibly adding some mystical component (chi), possibly not even that if your focus is more on martial arts specifically.

    And in basic English, “adept” just means “highly skilled at” something, so it’s too broad to narrow down to a single class.

    I realize that “Monk” is hardly the best term to represent this either; Christian monks hid in monasteries and were ascetics who practiced calligraphy and the like, and that would be my first association if I encountered the word in a non-game context. But “Adept” doesn’t feel like the right choice either; I hope you consider other options and come up with something as neat as “Wodewose” to convey the core nature of the class.

    • I hear you. Shadowrun has Physical Adepts, which is their martial artist. But we’re borrowing from A5E in this case, because it’s already there.
      I think the original Monk moniker appropriates from the Shaolin Monk tradition (or the old kung fu movies), and trying to find another name that’s not fraught would be incredibly challenging. In this case, unless we get a lot of feedback to the contrary, Adept seems to be our best option, especially since at least A5E players are familiar with it.
      But I’m glad you like Wodewose. I’m really happy that we found that one — to me, it seems to capture the class perfectly.

  3. Love all of the changes— except Game Conductor. I started using Game Moderator years ago— for all of the reasons you cited above. It the term we used in the RPG Social Justice curriculum we wrote and published. That way everyone can still say GM. GC… just doest have the same cache and familiarity.

    • Hey Craig! Moderator was our second choice, but it just felt stiff, political, corporate — not fun enough. Conductor has a lot of meanings that all seem to fit, whether movement, art, or energy.
      And we’re deliberately using Conductor instead of GC, since that abbreviation has a hurtful alternative meaning. If Keeper of Arcane Secrets in Call of Cthulhu can be abbreviated to Keeper, we’re hoping Conductor is still pretty easy to say.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>